5 minutes
When it’s time to replace your roof in Massachusetts, the two most popular options you’ll encounter are asphalt shingles and metal roofing. Both materials have their strengths, but which one is the better choice for your home, especially when facing New England’s unpredictable weather?
In this guide, we’ll break down the pros and cons of asphalt shingles and metal roofing, comparing cost, durability, energy efficiency, and more, so you can make an informed decision.
1. WHY YOUR ROOFING MATERIAL MATTERS IN MASSACHUSETTS
Massachusetts homeowners deal with unique weather challenges, including:
-
Heavy snow and ice in winter
-
Strong winds from Nor’easters
-
Hot, humid summers
-
Temperature fluctuations that cause expansion and contraction
Your roof needs to stand up to all of this and still look great while protecting your home. Let’s dive into how asphalt shingles and metal roofing measure up.
1. DURABILITY AND LIFESPAN
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Lifespan: 20-30 years
-
Weather resistance: Modern architectural shingles can withstand winds up to 110-130 mph. However, heavy snow and ice dams can wear down shingles over time.
-
Maintenance: May require occasional replacement of damaged shingles.
Metal Roofing:
-
Lifespan: 40-70+ years
-
Weather resistance: Metal roofs handle heavy snow, ice, and high winds exceptionally well. Snow slides off easily, reducing ice dam risks.
-
Maintenance: Minimal — occasional checks for rust (especially on older steel roofs).
✅ Winner: Metal Roofing — The longer lifespan and lower maintenance make it a top choice for durability.
2. COST
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Material cost: $3.50 - $5.50 per square foot (installed)
-
Total cost for average roof (2,000 sq. ft.): $7,000 - $11,000
-
Repair costs: Affordable and easy to fix individual shingles.
Metal Roofing:
-
Material cost: $6.00 - $14.00 per square foot (installed)
-
Total cost for average roof (2,000 sq. ft.): $12,000 - $28,000
-
Repair costs: Higher upfront, but rarely needs repairs.
✅ Winner: Asphalt Shingles — For upfront affordability, shingles take the prize.
3. ENERGY EFFICIENCY
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Heat absorption: Darker shingles absorb heat, which can make your home warmer in summer (unless you choose energy-efficient shingles).
-
Ventilation: Proper attic ventilation helps offset heat buildup.
Metal Roofing:
-
Reflectivity: Reflects solar heat, keeping homes cooler in summer.
-
Energy savings: Homeowners can see up to 25% lower cooling costs with metal roofs.
-
Insulation options: Can be paired with insulating layers for better winter performance.
✅ Winner: Metal Roofing — Especially for energy-conscious homeowners.
4. AESTHETIC APPEAL
Even if there are no visible problems yet, age alone can be a warning sign. Most commercial r
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Variety: Wide range of colors and styles to match any home.
-
Traditional look: Fits well with classic New England architecture.
Metal Roofing:
-
Modern and sleek: Available in panels, shingles, or standing seam styles.
-
Color variety: Powder-coated finishes offer customization.
-
Bold appearance: Best suited for contemporary or rustic farmhouse styles.
✅ Winner: Tie — This one’s all about personal preference.
Don’t Risk Downtime — Schedule a Commercial Roof Inspection Today
5. ENVIRONMENT IMPACT
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Recyclability: Limited — many shingles end up in landfills.
-
Production: Asphalt is a petroleum-based product, which impacts sustainability.
Metal Roofing:
-
Recyclable: Made from 25-95% recycled material and fully recyclable at the end of its life.
-
Eco-friendly production: Lower carbon footprint than asphalt.
✅ Winner: Metal Roofing — Better for the environment, hands down.
6. NOISE AND COMFORT
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Noise level: Quieter, especially during rain or hail.
-
Insulation: Offers basic sound and thermal insulation.
Metal Roofing:
-
Noise level: Can be noisier in rain and hail without proper underlayment.
-
Insulation: Reflects heat well but may need added insulation for winter warmth.
✅ Winner: Asphalt Shingles — Quieter and more comfortable without extra insulation.
7. RESALE VALUE
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Curb appeal: Widely accepted, but not considered a premium material.
-
Resale boost: May not significantly increase home value.
Metal Roofing:
-
Premium appeal: Often seen as an upgrade, especially with energy efficiency.
-
Resale boost: Can increase home value by 1-6% according to real estate studies.
✅ Winner: Metal Roofing — The longer lifespan and energy savings appeal to buyers.
Final Verdict: Which Roof is Right for Your Massachusetts Home?
Choose Asphalt Shingles if:
-
You want an affordable, reliable roof with a traditional look.
-
Your budget is tight, but you still need good weather protection.
-
Noise or added insulation is a concern.
Choose Metal Roofing if:
-
You’re staying in your home long-term and want maximum durability.
-
Energy efficiency and environmental impact are priorities.
-
You prefer a bold, modern aesthetic.
Still unsure which roof is right for you? Associated Roofing in Braintree, MA is here to help! Whether you lean toward asphalt shingles or a sleek metal roof, we’ll guide you to the best solution for your home and budget.
👉 Contact us today for a free roofing consultation!
